NEWS

Code & Contract

Industry Codes of Practice exist to ensure certain standards of behaviour are complied with in relation to particular services.

In this article, it will be discussed how the Codes of Practice are incorporated into contracts, such as mortgages and insurance policies.  A recent case in which alleged breaches of the Code of Banking Practice (Banking Code) such as  non-compliance with the Banking Code, material non-disclosure to Guarantors and unconscionable conduct by a bank were considered was National Australia Bank Limited v Timothy Craig Rice & John Albert Rose (NAB v Rice).[1] This was the first case in the Supreme Court of Victoria where it was found that breaches of the Banking Code rendered a contract void.

NAB v RICE

It was argued by NAB that the Banking Code did not impose any contractual obligation on it, but merely provided a desirable code of conduct;[2] however, the Court held that the Banking Code was contractually binding between NAB and Rose.[3] It was further determined that the terms of the Banking Code were to be treated as contractual terms of each of the guarantees. It did so on the basis that the breaches of the Banking Code caused the defendants loss.

Four points on which the defendants relied were:
1. unilateral mistake;
2. non-compliance with the Code of Banking Practice;
3. material non-disclosure by NAB; and
4. unconscionable conduct by NAB (which included alleged breaches of the Banking Code).

The Court held that NAB had breached the Banking Code in relation to non-compliance and non-disclosure.  NAB’s case was dismissed and the Court found that the breaches of the Banking Code by NAB, rendered the contract void.

GENERAL INSURANCE CODE OF PRACTICE

NAB v Rice[4]  illustrates a situation where non-compliance with an industry Code of Practice may render a contract void.  The General Insurance Code of Practice has the same compliance element as the Banking Code.  As such, Insurers need to comply with the General Insurance Code of Practice when issuing insurance policies.  In addition, the Insured has obligations under their insurance policy with the Insurer which incorporates the General Insurance Code of Practice.

NAB v Rice[5] was the first case where a Court found that non-compliance with the Banking Code rendered the contract void. This case demonstrates that Courts are now considering and determining that industry Codes of Practice are more than guidelines as to conduct to be followed, they are obligations incorporated into contracts.



[1] [2015] VSC 10
[2]
 Ibid 143
[3]
 Ibid 144
[4]
 [2015] VSC 10
[5]
 [2015] VSC 10

Related News

What happens if you, as an insurer, have not yet concluded whether or not to indemnify an insured, and a third party commences Court proceedings against your insured (with the indemnity decision still pending)?

When these types of claims arise, an insurer (and its panel firm) can continue to act for an insured on a “reservation of rights” basis.

Read More

Can you sue if a “registered” company is “in liquidation”, “under administration” or has become “deregistered”? 

It is common to see Court proceedings commenced in the name of an individual or against an individual.   But sometimes, Court proceedings are commenced by

Read More

The Briginshaw-test

Did you know that the Briginshaw-test requires a higher standard of evidence in civil matters where serious allegations are made, such as fraud. This principle

Read More

Get in touch

Contact our team today

Stay informed

Keep up-to-date with our regular news and insights

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
William Roberts Lawyers

Sydney

Level 22
66 Goulburn Street
SYDNEY NSW 2000

Melbourne

Level 21
535 Bourke Street
MELBOURNE VIC 3000

Brisbane

Level 8
300 Ann Street
BRISBANE QLD 4000

Singapore

Level 19
Singapore Land Tower
50 Raffles Place
SINGAPORE 048623